Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dudu Dekel's avatar

Strong piece. In narcotics cases I ran, the hardest files were the ones where the intelligence that justified the stop could never enter the courtroom without burning a source. So I wonder whether part of what you describe is a choice: Washington may simply value protecting the source picture over winning in Ecuadorian court. If so, the fix you propose works only once someone decides convictions are a goal at all.

Wahidullah Noorzai | NIDA's avatar

Jim, this analysis highlights a fundamental principle that is often overlooked in security operations: tactical success and legal success are not the same, and neither automatically produces a lasting strategic outcome.

From my experience in Afghanistan’s security environment, an operation must be assessed not only by what it disrupts or destroys, but also by the evidence it produces, the legitimacy it preserves, and the institutions capable of sustaining its results. When detention, intelligence collection, evidence preservation, and prosecution are treated as separate responsibilities rather than parts of one operational system, the gap between force and accountability can become a serious strategic weakness.

The destruction of a suspected vessel may eliminate a logistical asset, but if the operation also destroys potentially exculpatory or incriminating evidence, it can undermine the very case needed to establish responsibility. Allegations must be tested, evidence must be traceable, and the people conducting an operation must be able to account for their actions before a competent court. Otherwise, deterrence risks becoming a substitute for proof rather than an outcome supported by law.

There is a wider lesson here for counterterrorism and counterinsurgency as well. Security forces may achieve immediate operational effects while weakening public confidence, partner institutions, or the legal foundations of subsequent action. Those costs may not appear in an operational report, but they can shape the long-term outcome.

The real measure of an effective security operation is therefore not simply whether a target is removed. It is whether the operation produces a verifiable result that can withstand independent scrutiny, support lawful prosecution where warranted, and strengthen rather than erode the legitimacy of the wider security effort.

Force can disrupt a network. Evidence establishes responsibility. Lawful accountability is what makes the result defensible and sustainable.

4 more comments...

Ready for more?